Why we stopped weighing the water
For four years the bread recipe lived on a laminated card by the mixer. Seventy-two per cent hydration, two per cent salt, a hundred and eight grams of starter, twenty-six minutes of bulk per degree above eighteen. It made good bread. It also made exactly the same bread in January as in July, which sounds like a virtue and is not.
What the card could not know
Flour is an agricultural product. The protein in a sack from the mill up the valley moves by three or four per cent across a year depending on the harvest, the drying, and how long the sack sat. Seventy-two per cent of a thirsty flour is a different dough from seventy-two per cent of a weak one, and the card had no way of saying so.
We compensated the way everyone does — a splash more, a minute longer — and then wrote the splash down, until the card had fourteen conditional clauses and nobody read it.
Consistency is making the same decision every day. Sameness is making the same dough. They are not the same ambition.
The week it changed
In March the mill changed its blend without telling anyone. Three days of flat, grey loaves. On the fourth morning Teodor stopped weighing the water, poured until the dough felt right against the side of the bowl, and the bread came back.
Nothing mystical happened. He has made somewhere north of eleven thousand loaves and his hands hold a better model of this dough than a laminated card does. The card was a way of borrowing judgement he already had.
What we actually do now
- Flour, salt and starter are still weighed, because those are ratios and ratios do not lie.
- Water is poured by feel, and the amount is written down afterwards — a record, not an instruction.
- Anyone new weighs everything for their first three months. You cannot skip to the end of this.
- If the loaf is wrong we look at the log, and roughly half the time the answer is in it.
The part that is uncomfortable
This does not scale, and we know it. If we opened a second room tomorrow the bread would get worse before it got better, because the thing that makes it good is two pairs of hands that have been here long enough. We have decided we would rather have one room.
If you want the recipe: eighty-five per cent of what makes it work is the flour, and that costs forty per cent more than the commodity sack. Start there.